FanCashLearn More
Back to School. Up to 25% Off + Free Ship Over $39.
Use code SCHOOL
  1. NHL
  2. New York Islanders
  3. Matthew Schaefer
  4. Authentic Memorabilia
Authentic Memorabilia
1 - 10 of 10
10 Items10 Items
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic 10.5" x 13" Jersey Number Sublimated Player Plaque
$29.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic 10.5" x 13" Jersey Number Sublimated Player Plaque
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Showcase Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Most Popular
$79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Showcase Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Ships Free
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Celebration Spotlight Photograph
$9.99-$39.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Celebration Spotlight Photograph
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" 2026 Calder Trophy Winner Collage
$49.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" 2026 Calder Trophy Winner Collage
Ships Free
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic First NHL Goal Celebration Photograph
$9.99-$39.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic First NHL Goal Celebration Photograph
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Most Popular
$79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Ships Free
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
$79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
Ships Free
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" Radiance Collage
$49.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" Radiance Collage
Ships Free
Matthew Schaefer & Mathew Barzal New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
$79.99
Matthew Schaefer & Mathew Barzal New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
Ships Free
New York Islanders Personalized Puck
$39.99
New York Islanders Personalized Puck
Ships Free

Shop Players

Specialty Gear