FanCashLearn More
25% Off Savings.
Use code FLANNEL
  1. NHL
  2. New York Islanders
  3. Matthew Schaefer
1 - 72 of 101
101 Items101 Items
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Away Premium Jersey - White
Most Popular
$229.99
(See price in cart)
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Away Premium Jersey - White
FREE Jersey Assurance
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Home Breakaway Player Jerseys - Royal
Most Popular
$184.99
(See price in cart)
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Home Breakaway Player Jerseys - Royal
FREE Jersey Assurance
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Home Premium Jersey - Royal
Most Popular
$249.99
(See price in cart)
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Home Premium Jersey - Royal
FREE Jersey Assurance
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Women's Home Breakaway Player Jerseys - Royal
Most Popular
$184.99
(See price in cart)
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Women's Home Breakaway Player Jerseys - Royal
FREE Jersey Assurance
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Stack Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
Most Popular
$29.99 with code, regular $39.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Stack Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Outerstuff Youth Home Replica Player Jersey - Blue
Most Popular
$89.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Outerstuff Youth Home Replica Player Jersey - Blue
FREE Jersey Assurance
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Stack Name & Number Hoodie - Royal
Most Popular
$59.99 to $79.99 with code, regular $79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Stack Name & Number Hoodie - Royal
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders '47 Player Name & Number Lacer Hoodie - Royal
Most Popular
$119.99 to $159.99 with code, regular $159.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders '47 Player Name & Number Lacer Hoodie - Royal
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Most Popular
$59.99 with code, regular $79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fresh Ice T-Shirt - Black
$34.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fresh Ice T-Shirt - Black
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fresh Ice Hoodie - Charcoal
$59.99 with code, regular $74.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fresh Ice Hoodie - Charcoal
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic 10.5" x 13" Jersey Number Sublimated Player Plaque
$22.49 with code, regular $29.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic 10.5" x 13" Jersey Number Sublimated Player Plaque
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders '47 City Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
Most Popular
$31.49 with code, regular $41.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders '47 City Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic First NHL Goal Celebration Photograph
$7.49 to $29.99 with code, regular $9.99 to $39.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic First NHL Goal Celebration Photograph
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" 2026 Calder Trophy Winner Collage
$37.49 with code, regular $49.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" 2026 Calder Trophy Winner Collage
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Celebration Spotlight Photograph
$7.49 to $29.99 with code, regular $9.99 to $39.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Unsigned Fanatics Authentic NHL Record Most Goals By An 18-Year-Old Defenseman Celebration Spotlight Photograph
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Big & Tall Heat Check Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Big & Tall Heat Check Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Showcase Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Most Popular
$59.99 with code, regular $79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Showcase Collage with a Piece of Game-Used Puck - Limited Edition of 250
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Youth 2026 Calder Memorial Trophy Winner T-Shirt - Black
$20.99 with code, regular $34.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Youth 2026 Calder Memorial Trophy Winner T-Shirt - Black
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Highland Mint 13" x 13" Impact Jersey Framed Photo
$37.49 with code, regular $49.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Highland Mint 13" x 13" Impact Jersey Framed Photo
Matthew Schaefer New Era Player Spotlight Name & Number T-Shirt - Black
$23.99 with code, regular $39.99
Matthew Schaefer New Era Player Spotlight Name & Number T-Shirt - Black
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" Radiance Collage
$37.49 with code, regular $49.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Fanatics Authentic Framed 13" x 16" Radiance Collage
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
$59.99 with code, regular $79.99
Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
New York Islanders Fanatics 2024 Hockey Fights Cancer Custom Practice Jersey - White
$159.99
New York Islanders Fanatics 2024 Hockey Fights Cancer Custom Practice Jersey - White
New York Islanders Fanatics Home Premium Custom Jersey - Royal
$269.99
New York Islanders Fanatics Home Premium Custom Jersey - Royal
New York Islanders Fanatics Home Breakaway Custom Jersey - Blue
$204.99
New York Islanders Fanatics Home Breakaway Custom Jersey - Blue
New York Islanders Fanatics 2024 Military Appreciation Custom Practice Jersey - Black
$159.99
New York Islanders Fanatics 2024 Military Appreciation Custom Practice Jersey - Black
New York Islanders Personalized Midnight Mascot Logo T-Shirt - Black
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders Personalized Midnight Mascot Logo T-Shirt - Black
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Black
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Black
New York Islanders Women's Heritage Custom Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Gray
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
New York Islanders Women's Heritage Custom Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Gray
New York Islanders Personalized Midnight Mascot Logo Pullover Hoodie - Black
$59.99 with code, regular $74.99
New York Islanders Personalized Midnight Mascot Logo Pullover Hoodie - Black
New York Islanders Fanatics Away Premium Custom Jersey - White
$269.99
New York Islanders Fanatics Away Premium Custom Jersey - White
New York Islanders Big & Tall Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Black
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
New York Islanders Big & Tall Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Black
New York Islanders Heritage Custom Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Gray
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
New York Islanders Heritage Custom Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Gray
New York Islanders Personalized Name & Number Midfielder T-Shirt - Royal
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders Personalized Name & Number Midfielder T-Shirt - Royal
New York Islanders Hustle Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
$35.99 with code, regular $44.99
New York Islanders Hustle Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
New York Islanders Fanatics Women's Home Breakaway Custom Jersey - Blue
Most Popular
$204.99
New York Islanders Fanatics Women's Home Breakaway Custom Jersey - Blue
New York Islanders Big & Tall Hustle Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
New York Islanders Big & Tall Hustle Personalized Name & Number T-Shirt - Royal
New York Islanders Personalized Name & Number Midfielder Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Royal
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
New York Islanders Personalized Name & Number Midfielder Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Royal
New York Islanders Personalized Name & Number Midfielder Pullover Hoodie - Royal
$59.99 with code, regular $74.99
New York Islanders Personalized Name & Number Midfielder Pullover Hoodie - Royal
New York Islanders Big & Tall Personalized Name & Number Monochrome T-Shirt - Gray
$35.99 with code, regular $44.99
New York Islanders Big & Tall Personalized Name & Number Monochrome T-Shirt - Gray
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Sweatshirt - Black
$55.99 with code, regular $69.99
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Sweatshirt - Black
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Hoodie - Black
$60.79 with code, regular $75.99
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Hoodie - Black
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Black
$35.99 with code, regular $44.99
New York Islanders Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Black
New York Islanders Hustle Personalized Name & Number Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Royal
$39.99 with code, regular $49.99
New York Islanders Hustle Personalized Name & Number Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Royal
New York Islanders Big & Tall Personalized Name & Number Monochrome Pullover Hoodie - Gray
$79.99
New York Islanders Big & Tall Personalized Name & Number Monochrome Pullover Hoodie - Gray
New York Islanders WinCraft 20'' x 30'' Personalized Floor Mat
$35.99 with code, regular $44.99
New York Islanders WinCraft 20'' x 30'' Personalized Floor Mat
New York Islanders Big & Tall Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Hoodie - Black
$67.99 with code, regular $84.99
New York Islanders Big & Tall Home Ice Pop Personalized Name & Number Hoodie - Black
New York Islanders WinCraft 3' x 5' One-Sided Deluxe Personalized Flag
$43.99 with code, regular $54.99
New York Islanders WinCraft 3' x 5' One-Sided Deluxe Personalized Flag
New York Islanders Youth Home Replica Custom Jersey - Royal
$109.99
New York Islanders Youth Home Replica Custom Jersey - Royal
New York Islanders Fanatics Home Authentic Pro Custom Jersey - Royal
$499.99
New York Islanders Fanatics Home Authentic Pro Custom Jersey - Royal
Almost Gone
New York Islanders WinCraft Personalized 27'' x 37'' Single-Sided Vertical Banner
$36.79 with code, regular $45.99
New York Islanders WinCraft Personalized 27'' x 37'' Single-Sided Vertical Banner
Matthew Schaefer & Mathew Barzal New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
Most Popular
$59.99 with code, regular $79.99
Matthew Schaefer & Mathew Barzal New York Islanders Facsimile Signature Fanatics Authentic Framed 11" x 14" Spotlight Photograph
New York Islanders Personalized Puck
Most Popular
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders Personalized Puck
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Team Color Draft Tumbler
$34.39 with code, regular $42.99
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Team Color Draft Tumbler
New York Islanders 6" x 12" Personalized Mr. & Mrs. Script Sign
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders 6" x 12" Personalized Mr. & Mrs. Script Sign
New York Islanders Keyscaper Personalized Endzone Solid PopSockets Magnetic Phone Grip & Stand
$43.99 with code, regular $54.99
New York Islanders Keyscaper Personalized Endzone Solid PopSockets Magnetic Phone Grip & Stand
New York Islanders Divot Tool & Golf Ball Personalized Tin Gift Set
$23.99 with code, regular $29.99
New York Islanders Divot Tool & Golf Ball Personalized Tin Gift Set
New York Islanders 18oz. Personalized Hustle Mug
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders 18oz. Personalized Hustle Mug
New York Islanders 4" Personalized Circular Coasters 4-Pack Set
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders 4" Personalized Circular Coasters 4-Pack Set
New York Islanders Keyscaper Personalized 15W Fast Wireless Charger and Mouse Pad
$69.99
New York Islanders Keyscaper Personalized 15W Fast Wireless Charger and Mouse Pad
New York Islanders 16" Personalized Circle Wall Art
$27.99 with code, regular $34.99
New York Islanders 16" Personalized Circle Wall Art
New York Islanders 16" Customizable Garage Circle
$27.99 with code, regular $34.99
New York Islanders 16" Customizable Garage Circle
New York Islanders 6oz. Personalized Stealth Hip Flask - Black
$27.99 with code, regular $34.99
New York Islanders 6oz. Personalized Stealth Hip Flask - Black
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Stealth Draft Tumbler - Black
$30.39 with code, regular $37.99
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Stealth Draft Tumbler - Black
New York Islanders 24" Personalized Barrel Top
$83.99 with code, regular $104.99
New York Islanders 24" Personalized Barrel Top
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Opal Draft Tumbler
$31.99 with code, regular $39.99
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Opal Draft Tumbler
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Stealth Draft Beverage Cup - Black
$30.39 with code, regular $37.99
New York Islanders 24oz. Personalized Stealth Draft Beverage Cup - Black
New York Islanders 4-Pack Personalized Leather Coaster Set
$51.99 with code, regular $64.99
New York Islanders 4-Pack Personalized Leather Coaster Set
New York Islanders Team Logo 16oz. Personalized Laser Etched Jump Mug
$27.99 with code, regular $34.99
New York Islanders Team Logo 16oz. Personalized Laser Etched Jump Mug
New York Islanders Divot Tool & Golf Chip Personalized Tin Gift Set
$23.99 with code, regular $29.99
New York Islanders Divot Tool & Golf Chip Personalized Tin Gift Set
New York Islanders Divot Tool & Ball Markers Personalized Tin Gift Set
$23.99 with code, regular $29.99
New York Islanders Divot Tool & Ball Markers Personalized Tin Gift Set

Official Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders Jerseys, Matthew Schaefer Apparel & Matthew Schaefer Gear

Get official Matthew Schaefer New York Islanders jerseys and gear at Fanatics.com and show your support for every big game, or to wear everyday. From authentic Matthew Schaefer Islanders jerseys to shirts, collectibles, and more, Fanatics is your trusted source for officially licensed gear. Find the widest selection of styles, sizes, and colors to represent your favorite Islanders star. Complete your collection with Matthew Schaefer memorabilia and check back often for the latest arrivals. When it comes to Matthew Schaefer Islanders apparel and merchandise, Fanatics.com is the ultimate destination.

Shop Players

Specialty Gear