Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Auctions
Gift Cards
Track Order
Help
My Account
Fanatics ONE
FanCash
Learn More
Men
Women
More
Kids
Jerseys
T-Shirts
Sweatshirts
Hats
Collectibles
Kids
Jerseys
T-Shirts
More
Sweatshirts
Hats
Collectibles
Sweatshirts
Hats
Collectibles
Sale
FREE U.S. Shipping on Orders Over $39.
Use code
39SHIP
Terms
NFL
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards
false
Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
Indianapolis Colts
Trading Cards
false
Rookie Card
Trading Card Departments
Singles
Featured Brands
Topps
Upper Deck
Decade
1990-1999
2010-2019
2020-2029
Authenticator
Beckett
CGC
PSA
SGC
Grade
9
9.5
10
Price Range / Sale
$25 to $50
$50 to $100
$100 to $150
Over $150
Trading Cards
Filters
1 - 72 of 74
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
1
2
1
2
next page
Indianapolis Colts
Trading Cards
false
Rookie Card
74 Items
74 Items
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Prizm #332 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Donruss Rated Rookie #317 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card with "Horse Power" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Bowman Chrome #161 CGC Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Auto 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$279.99
Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1994 Topps #445 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card with "HOF 20XI" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck UD3 FE #1 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$279.99
Tyler Warren Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2025 Panini National Treasures Treasured Impressions Relic #RTI-TWN #16/25 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$30.00
2017 Panini Contenders Cracked Ice #354 Marlon Mack RC Auto /25
$479.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Score #233 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Bowman #161 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Phoenix Fire Burst #118 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Skybox E-X2001 #54 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck UD3 FR #181 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select #253 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$429.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck SPX Finite #287 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$349.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Donruss Rated Rookie #317 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card with "Horse Power" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select #53 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Donruss Rated Rookie #317 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Bowman's Best #112 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$429.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Score #233 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck SPX The New School #311 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$179.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Bowman Chrome #161 CGC Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select #53 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$149.99
Laiatu Latu Indianapolis Colts 2024 Panini Obsidian Fire & Ice Gold Prizm #6 #1/10 PSA Authenticated 9 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps #339 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Pacific Omega #101 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Bowman #161 CGC Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Auto 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$79.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts 2023 Panini Select Green & Yellow Die Cut Prizm #43 SGC Authenticated 9 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$109.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts 2023 Panini Donruss Rated Rookie #343 SGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$99.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts 2023 Panini Mosaic Green Prizm #ND-5 SGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$99.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts 2023 Panini Mosaic Silver Prizm #ND-5 SGC Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Luminance Teal #215 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9.5/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Luminance #215 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9.5/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Donruss Clearly Rated Rookie #RR-JT Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$279.99
Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1994 Upper Deck SP #3 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card with "HOF 20XI" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$279.99
Marshall Faulk Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1994 Upper Deck SP #3 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card with "OROY 94" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$279.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Donruss Rated Rookie #317 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Rookie Card with "Horse Power" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select #253 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9.5/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$299.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select #53 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9.5/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$549.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Skybox E-X2001 #54 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck SPX Finite Radiance #287 #1043/3600 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Topps Star #67 #/8799 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$429.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck SPX Finite Radiance #287 #1541/3600 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps #339 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select Purple Prizm Die Cut #53 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Fleer Tradition #235 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck UD3 Future Shock Light Blue Ink #FS1 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Pacific Crown Royale #54 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Topps Stadium Club 1998 NFL Draft Pick #195 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Topps Stadium Club #195 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck UD3 FF #91 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Upper Deck SPX Finite #351 #/2700 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$499.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Bowman's Best Performers #BP1 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Select Red Prizm Die Cut #253 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$479.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Topps Star #67 #/8799 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$599.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1998 Topps Stadium Club #195 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 10 Rookie Card with "HOF 21" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2023 Panini Clearly Donruss Blue #52 #89/99 PSA Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$479.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2023 Panini Zenith 2 Color Relic #202 #127/299 PSA Authenticated 9 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$709.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2023 Panini Flawless Rookie Debut #RDS-ARI #3/20 SGC Authenticated 9/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$149.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts 2023 Panini Phoenix Pink Prizm #103 #4/199 PSA Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$449.99
Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts 2023 Panini Obsidian Black Color Blast #17 SGC Authenticated 9 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$749.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini National Treasures Dual-Color RPA #172 #49/99 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$399.99
Riley Leonard Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2025 Panini Phoenix Ascension NFLPA Logo Relic #ARJ-RLD #2/3 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps Bowman's Best #115 CGC Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Auto 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps Bowman's Best #115 CGC Authenticated Mint 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$549.99
Tyler Warren Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2025 Panini Flawless Holo Silver Rookie Dual Patch Dual-Color Relics #RDPA-TWN #11/20 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$179.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps Bowman's Best #115 CGC Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$279.99
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts Autographed 2020 Panini Playoff #218 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated Rookie Card with "Horse Power" Inscription
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps Bowman's Best #115 CGC Authenticated 9.5/9 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$199.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Bowman Chrome #161 CGC Authenticated Mint 9 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$229.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Bowman Chrome #161 CGC Authenticated Mint 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$249.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts Autographed 1999 Topps Bowman's Best #115 CGC Authenticated 9.5/10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
$1,399.99
Edgerrin James Indianapolis Colts 1999 Upper Deck SP Authentics Future Watch #94 #10/25 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1
2
1
2
next page
