Afterpay: Shop Your Match-Day Look. Pay Later.
FanCashLearn More
DEAL ENDS SOON!
  1. MLB
  2. Trading Cards
  3. $40 to $60
Trading Cards
1 - 72 of 75
75 Items75 Items
Chris Sale Atlanta Braves 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CS BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Chris Sale Atlanta Braves 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CS BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Colt Keith Detroit Tigers 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC3 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Colt Keith Detroit Tigers 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC3 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Christian Yelich Milwaukee Brewers 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CY BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Christian Yelich Milwaukee Brewers 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CY BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Salvador Perez Kansas City Royals 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SP BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Salvador Perez Kansas City Royals 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SP BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Manny Machado San Diego Padres 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection NL #ASG-MM BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Manny Machado San Diego Padres 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection NL #ASG-MM BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Brooks Lee Minnesota Twins 2025 Topps Living Set #825 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Brooks Lee Minnesota Twins 2025 Topps Living Set #825 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Ketel Marte Arizona Diamondbacks 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - NL #ASG-KM BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Ketel Marte Arizona Diamondbacks 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - NL #ASG-KM BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Francisco Lindor New York Mets 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection NL #ASG-FL BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Francisco Lindor New York Mets 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection NL #ASG-FL BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Adley Rutschman Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps TBT 90 Topps Ames All-Stars #94 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Adley Rutschman Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps TBT 90 Topps Ames All-Stars #94 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Colton Cowser Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CC BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Colton Cowser Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CC BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Kyle Tucker Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now MLB All-Star Game Selection - NL #ASG-KT BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
$49.99
Kyle Tucker Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now MLB All-Star Game Selection - NL #ASG-KT BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Javier Báez Detroit Tigers 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-JB BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Javier Báez Detroit Tigers 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-JB BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Zack Wheeler Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-187 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Zack Wheeler Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-187 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now Astros Top Prospect Collects Hit in MLB Debut #9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now Astros Top Prospect Collects Hit in MLB Debut #9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now 1st Big League Homer Caps Houston's Big Win #58 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now 1st Big League Homer Caps Houston's Big Win #58 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Moisés Ballesteros Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now Highly Touted Prospect Logs 1st Career Hit & RBI #186 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Moisés Ballesteros Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now Highly Touted Prospect Logs 1st Career Hit & RBI #186 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Michael Harris Atlanta Braves 2022 Topps Now 2022 NL Rookie of The Year Award Winner 11.14.2022 #OS-35 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Michael Harris Atlanta Braves 2022 Topps Now 2022 NL Rookie of The Year Award Winner 11.14.2022 #OS-35 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Hunter Greene Cincinnati Reds 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-HG BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Hunter Greene Cincinnati Reds 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-HG BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Aaron Nola Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-AN BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Aaron Nola Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-AN BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now Rookie Cup Team #RC1 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2024 Topps Now Rookie Cup Team #RC1 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Colton Cowser Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Colton Cowser Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Royce Lewis Minnesota Twins 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-RL BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Royce Lewis Minnesota Twins 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-RL BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-JR BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-JR BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now Happy Hollidays! 1st MLB HR is Grand Slam 07.31.24 #498 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now Happy Hollidays! 1st MLB HR is Grand Slam 07.31.24 #498 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Brandon Nimmo New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-174 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Brandon Nimmo New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-174 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Shane McClanahan Tampa Bay Rays 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SM BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Shane McClanahan Tampa Bay Rays 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SM BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Michael Busch Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #ODB11 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Michael Busch Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #ODB11 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Alec Bohm Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-188 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Alec Bohm Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-188 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Gerrit Cole New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-22 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Gerrit Cole New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-22 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Sean Manaea New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-175 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Sean Manaea New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-175 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Johan Rojas Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-190 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Johan Rojas Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-190 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Kodai Senga New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-177 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Kodai Senga New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-177 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Brenton Doyle Colorado Rockies 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SH BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Brenton Doyle Colorado Rockies 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SH BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Corbin Burnes Arizona Diamondbacks 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CB BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Corbin Burnes Arizona Diamondbacks 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-CB BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Juan Soto New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-171 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Juan Soto New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-171 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Polar Power New Mets HR King After 253rd Longball #553 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
$49.99
$69.99
Clearance
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Polar Power New Mets HR King After 253rd Longball #553 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Marcelo Mayer Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Connects For 1st Career HR at Yankee Stadium #266 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Marcelo Mayer Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Connects For 1st Career HR at Yankee Stadium #266 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Kristian Campbell Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now 22 Year Old Prospect Notches 1st Hit in MLB Debut #11 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Kristian Campbell Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now 22 Year Old Prospect Notches 1st Hit in MLB Debut #11 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jac Caglianone Kansas City Royals 2025 Topps Now Call Up Club Top Prospect Rips RBI Double for 1st MLB Hit #262 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Jac Caglianone Kansas City Royals 2025 Topps Now Call Up Club Top Prospect Rips RBI Double for 1st MLB Hit #262 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now 1st Opening Day Leadoff HR in Yankees History #8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now 1st Opening Day Leadoff HR in Yankees History #8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jonah Tong New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Call Up The Canadian Cannon is Victorious in MLB Debut #628 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Jonah Tong New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Call Up The Canadian Cannon is Victorious in MLB Debut #628 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Riley Greene Detroit Tigers 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-RG BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Riley Greene Detroit Tigers 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-RG BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Gleyber Torres Detroit Tigers 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-GT BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Gleyber Torres Detroit Tigers 2025 Topps Now 2025 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-GT BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Cedric Mullins Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-3 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Cedric Mullins Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-3 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Adley Rutschman Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-2 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Adley Rutschman Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-2 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Coby Mayo Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-4 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Coby Mayo Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-4 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Oneil Cruz Pittsburgh Pirates 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-232 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Oneil Cruz Pittsburgh Pirates 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-232 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-8 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Heston Kjerstad Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-7 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Heston Kjerstad Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-7 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jordan Westburg Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Jordan Westburg Baltimore Orioles 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Michael Harris II Atlanta Braves 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-152 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Michael Harris II Atlanta Braves 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-152 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Nick Yorke Pittsburgh Pirates 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-240 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Nick Yorke Pittsburgh Pirates 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-240 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Edwin Díaz New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-180 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
$49.99
Edwin Díaz New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-180 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Francisco Lindor New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-176 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Francisco Lindor New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-176 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Trevor Story Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-14 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Trevor Story Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-14 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-28 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-28 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Trea Turner Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-183 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Trea Turner Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-183 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Max Fried New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-27 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Max Fried New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-27 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Triston Casas Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-18 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Triston Casas Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-18 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Mark Vientos New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-179 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Mark Vientos New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-179 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Francisco Alvarez New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-178 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Francisco Alvarez New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-178 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Luis Gil New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-30 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Luis Gil New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-30 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Bryson Stott Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-186 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Bryson Stott Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-186 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Aaron Nola Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-185 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Aaron Nola Philadelphia Phillies 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-185 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Masataka Yoshida Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-15 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Masataka Yoshida Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-15 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-25 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-25 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Sandy Alcantara Miami Marlins 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SA BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
$49.99
Sandy Alcantara Miami Marlins 2025 Topps Now Lou Gehrig Day #LGD-SA BGS Authenticated 9.5 Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone
1965 Topps #437 Chico Cardenas BGS 9
$51.00
1965 Topps #437 Chico Cardenas BGS 9
Ships Free
Rafael Devers Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road To Opening Day Red Foil #OD-11 #/5 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
$59.99
$99.99
Clearance
Rafael Devers Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now Road To Opening Day Red Foil #OD-11 #/5 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Polar Power New Mets HR King After 253rd Longball #553 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
$49.99
$69.99
Clearance
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Polar Power New Mets HR King After 253rd Longball #553 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-172 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
$49.99
$69.99
Clearance
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2025 Topps Now Road to Opening Day #OD-172 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Grant Holmes Atlanta Braves 2025 Topps Now Racks up Career-High 15Ks in Dominant Start #ODB9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
$49.99
Grant Holmes Atlanta Braves 2025 Topps Now Racks up Career-High 15Ks in Dominant Start #ODB9 BGS Authenticated 9.5 Rookie Card
Ships Free
Almost Gone

Trending MLB Collections