Skip to Accessibility Statement
Skip to Main Content
Skip to Filters
Skip to Filters
Skip to Footer
Sign In
Indianapolis Colts
Men
Women
Kids
Jerseys
T-Shirts
Sweatshirts
Hats
Collectibles
Sale
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards
Indianapolis Colts
Filter & Sort
Cancel
Your Selections
Trading Cards
$25 to $50
Leagues
NFL
MLB
NBA
NHL
Unlicensed Product
Trading Card Departments
Boxes and Sets
Card Supplies
Singles
Featured Brands
Fanatics Authentic
Topps
Decade
1990-1999
2000-2009
2010-2019
2020-2029
Trading Card Features
Graded
Hobby Boxes
Inscribed
Raw
Rookie Card
Serial Numbered
Filters
1 - 52 of 52
Top Sellers
LowestPrice
HighestPrice
TopSellers
NewestArrivals
72 Items
24
48
72
NFL
MLB
NBA
NHL
Unlicensed Product
Trading Cards
$25 to $50
52 Items
52 Items
262 sold today
$29.99
2026 Topps Flagship Football Factory Sealed Fanatics Exclusive Value Box
$29.99
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Trading Cards Set
$29.99
Indianapolis Colts Team Trading Card Pack
$32.99
Indianapolis Colts 6" x 8" Player Plaque & 2024 Team Trading Card Set
$27.00
2021 Panini Contenders Optic Orange #178 Kylen Granson AU
$27.00
2007 Leaf Rookies and Stars Longevity Materials Sapphire #80 Peyton Manning
$35.00
2024 Panini Spectra Icons Autographs #14 Jeff Saturday/149
$27.00
2021 Select Prizm Dragon Scale #98 Sam Ehlinger
$36.00
2021 Panini Elements Future Signs Blue #6 Kwity Paye
$27.00
2009 Topps Platinum Autographed Patches #ARPJA Joseph Addai/110
$36.00
1999 Playoff Prestige SSD Inside the Numbers #IN12 Edgerrin James/1416*
$27.00
2021 Select Prizm White Die Cut #35 Peyton Manning
$36.00
2021 Panini Contenders #246A Sam Ehlinger AU RC
$27.00
2021 Panini National Treasures Jersey Number Red #108 Kwity Paye AU/51
$35.00
2021 Donruss Optic Rated Rookies Autographs Pink Velocity #248 Kwity Paye
$36.00
2020 Panini Illusions Rookie Endorsements #5 Jacob Eason/99
$27.00
1999 Playoff Prestige SSD Gridiron Heritage #GH5 Peyton Manning
$30.00
2020 Zenith #99 Michael Pittman Jr. JSY AU/99
$27.00
2022 Panini National Convention VIP Prizm #17 Peyton Manning
$36.00
1998 Playoff Momentum Rookie Double Feature Hobby #1 P.Manning/B.Griese
$32.00
1998 UD Choice Prime Choice Reserve #273 Jerome Pathon DN
$27.00
2022 Panini Contenders Optic Silver #172 Jelani Woods AU
$32.00
2000 Revolution Red #39 Peyton Manning
$36.00
2020 Panini Mosaic Mosaic Choice Fusion Red #299 Peyton Manning MVP
$40.00
2022 Panini Contenders Optic Black Pulsar #26 Jonathan Taylor
$27.00
2022 Panini Prizm Prizms Black and White Checker #122 Jonathan Taylor
$32.00
2020 Panini Contenders #227 Rodrigo Blankenship AU RC
$27.00
2022 Classics Premium Edition Significant Signatures H2 Purple #42 Michael Pittman Jr./20
$27.00
1999 SkyBox Molten Metal Top Notch Gold #TN10 Edgerrin James
$27.00
2020 Panini Mosaic Silver #236 Jacob Eason
$36.00
2020 Panini Mosaic Mosaic Choice Fusion Red #90 Peyton Manning
$36.00
2021 Panini National Treasures Tremendous Treasures Rookie Materials Holo Silver #46 Sam Ehlinger
$27.00
2021 Panini Contenders Optic #152 Kwity Paye AU RC
$27.00
2021 Select Prizm Red #35 Peyton Manning
$32.00
1999 Upper Deck HoloGrFX 24/7 Gold #N11 Edgerrin James
$30.00
2023 Panini National Convention Green #18 Jonathan Taylor
$36.00
2020 Donruss Clearly Rated Rookie Autographs #6 Jacob Eason
$27.00
2020 Panini Mosaic Mosaic #280 Jacob Eason DEB
$36.00
2020 Panini Prizm Prizms Red Wave #333 Michael Pittman Jr.
$36.00
2012 Topps Chrome Rookie Autographs Camo Refractors #17 Dwayne Allen
$40.00
1998 UD3 #91 Peyton Manning FF
$30.00
2017 Panini Contenders Cracked Ice #354 Marlon Mack RC Auto /25
$45.00
2020 Panini Obsidian Rookie Jersey Ink #36 Jacob Eason/150
$45.00
2025 Topps Chrome Lightboard Logo Variation #126 Michael Pittman Jr.
$45.00
2021 Panini Mosaic Rookie Autographs Mosaic Choice Fusion Red and Yellow #62 Sam Ehlinger
$45.00
2020 Select Rookie Selections Prizm #16 Jonathan Taylor
$45.00
2020 Select Select Certified Rookies Prizm #16 Jonathan Taylor
$45.00
2020 Panini Obsidian Rookie Jersey Autographs #236 Jacob Eason/150
$45.00
2021 Panini Contenders Optic Purple Pulsar #178 Kylen Granson AU
$45.00
2021 Panini Mosaic Mosaic Genesis #351 Kwity Paye
$45.00
2021 Panini Contenders Playoff Ticket #152A Kwity Paye AU
In 14 carts
$29.99
Fanatics Authentic Acrylic Magnetic Encased Trading Card Display - UV Protected & Fits Any Grading Company
1
1
