Spend $25 on select ice cream, score $50 with Fanatics.
FanCashLearn More
DEAL ENDS SOON!
  1. Cooperstown Teams
  2. Hot New Arrivals
Hot New Arrivals
1 - 72 of 243
243 Items243 Items
Cleveland Indians New Era America 250 39THIRTY Flex Hat - Black
Most Popular
$41.99
Cleveland Indians New Era America 250 39THIRTY Flex Hat - Black
Ships Free
Montreal Expos Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Heritage Ballpark Snapback Hat - Cream/Blue
Most Popular
$33.99
Montreal Expos Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Heritage Ballpark Snapback Hat - Cream/Blue
Florida Marlins Mitchell & Ness Unisex 1904 Soft Wash Cooperstown Adjustable Hat - Teal
$32.00
Florida Marlins Mitchell & Ness Unisex 1904 Soft Wash Cooperstown Adjustable Hat - Teal
Florida Marlins Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
$39.99
Florida Marlins Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Jackie Robinson Brooklyn Dodgers Homage Signature Name & Number Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Stone
$37.99
Jackie Robinson Brooklyn Dodgers Homage Signature Name & Number Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Stone
Montreal Expos Champion Cooperstown Logo Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Blue
Most Popular
$39.99
Montreal Expos Champion Cooperstown Logo Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Blue
Ships Free
Florida Marlins Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Heritage Ballpark Snapback Hat - Cream/Black
$33.99
Florida Marlins Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Heritage Ballpark Snapback Hat - Cream/Black
Brooklyn Dodgers Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
$39.99
Brooklyn Dodgers Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
Ships Free
California Angels Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Heritage Ballpark Snapback Hat - Cream/Navy
$33.99
California Angels Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Heritage Ballpark Snapback Hat - Cream/Navy
Oakland Athletics New Era Youth 9FIFTY Trucker Snapback Hat - Green
Most Popular
$36.99
Oakland Athletics New Era Youth 9FIFTY Trucker Snapback Hat - Green
Brooklyn Dodgers Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
$39.99
Brooklyn Dodgers Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
Ships Free
California Angels Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
$39.99
California Angels Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
Ships Free
Montreal Expos Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
$39.99
Montreal Expos Mitchell & Ness Unisex Retro Arch Pro Pinch Adjustable Hat - Cream
Ships Free
California Angels Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
$39.99
California Angels Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
Ships Free
Brooklyn Dodgers Nike Cooperstown 2-Hit T-Shirt - Heather Gray
$44.99
Brooklyn Dodgers Nike Cooperstown 2-Hit T-Shirt - Heather Gray
Ships Free
Montreal Expos Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
$39.99
Montreal Expos Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
Ships Free
Florida Marlins Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Recall Snapback Hat - Teal/White
$29.99
Florida Marlins Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Recall Snapback Hat - Teal/White
Montreal Expos Fanatics Heritage Scar Adjustable Hat - Royal/Cream
$31.99
Montreal Expos Fanatics Heritage Scar Adjustable Hat - Royal/Cream
Oakland Athletics Fanatics Heritage Concourse A-Frame Adjustable Hat - Green
$33.99
Oakland Athletics Fanatics Heritage Concourse A-Frame Adjustable Hat - Green
Montreal Expos Fanatics Tape Measure Cuffed Knit Hat with Pom - Royal
$29.99
Montreal Expos Fanatics Tape Measure Cuffed Knit Hat with Pom - Royal
Montreal Expos Fanatics Heritage Concourse A-Frame Adjustable Hat - Royal
$33.99
Montreal Expos Fanatics Heritage Concourse A-Frame Adjustable Hat - Royal
Florida Marlins Fanatics Heritage Concourse A-Frame Adjustable Hat - Black
$33.99
Florida Marlins Fanatics Heritage Concourse A-Frame Adjustable Hat - Black
Florida Marlins Fanatics Heritage Scar Adjustable Hat - Black/Cream
$31.99
Florida Marlins Fanatics Heritage Scar Adjustable Hat - Black/Cream
Florida Marlins Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
$39.99
Florida Marlins Mitchell & Ness Unisex Snow Block Pro Crown Adjustable Hat - Cream/Black
Ships Free
Brooklyn Dodgers Nike Cooperstown Rise Adjustable Hat - Royal
$37.99
Brooklyn Dodgers Nike Cooperstown Rise Adjustable Hat - Royal
California Angels Fanatics Heritage Scar Adjustable Hat - Navy/Cream
$31.99
California Angels Fanatics Heritage Scar Adjustable Hat - Navy/Cream
Oakland Athletics Nike Women's Authentic Collection Legend Performance Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Green
$44.99
Oakland Athletics Nike Women's Authentic Collection Legend Performance Long Sleeve T-Shirt - Green
Ships Free
Almost Gone
Oakland Athletics Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Recall Snapback Hat - Gold/White
$29.99
Oakland Athletics Fanatics Cooperstown Collection Recall Snapback Hat - Gold/White
California Angels '47 Cooperstown Collection Clean Up Adjustable Hat - Navy/Light Blue
Most Popular
$34.99
California Angels '47 Cooperstown Collection Clean Up Adjustable Hat - Navy/Light Blue
Florida Marlins Starter Distressed Cooperstown Diamond T-Shirt - Cream
Most Popular
$44.99
Florida Marlins Starter Distressed Cooperstown Diamond T-Shirt - Cream
Ships Free
Brooklyn Dodgers New Era 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame 9FORTY M-Crown Adjustable Hat - White/Royal
$37.99
Brooklyn Dodgers New Era 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame 9FORTY M-Crown Adjustable Hat - White/Royal
Montreal Expos Champion Cooperstown Wordmark Lockup Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Blue
Most Popular
$39.99
Montreal Expos Champion Cooperstown Wordmark Lockup Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Blue
Ships Free
Milwaukee Braves New Era 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame 9FORTY M-Crown Adjustable Hat - Navy
$37.99
Milwaukee Braves New Era 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame 9FORTY M-Crown Adjustable Hat - Navy
Brooklyn Dodgers Champion Cooperstown Logo Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Royal
$39.99
Brooklyn Dodgers Champion Cooperstown Logo Tri-Blend T-Shirt - Royal
Ships Free
Brooklyn Dodgers Throwback Pet Jersey
$35.99
Brooklyn Dodgers Throwback Pet Jersey
Oakland Athletics Victus Sports Mini Bat Bottle Opener
Most Popular
$29.99
Oakland Athletics Victus Sports Mini Bat Bottle Opener
Almost Gone
Oakland Athletics Champion Women's Boyfriend Cropped Americana T-Shirt - White
$36.99
Oakland Athletics Champion Women's Boyfriend Cropped Americana T-Shirt - White
California Angels Mitchell & Ness Youth Retro Logo T-Shirt - Navy
$29.99
California Angels Mitchell & Ness Youth Retro Logo T-Shirt - Navy
Montreal Expos Throwback Pet Jersey
$35.99
Montreal Expos Throwback Pet Jersey
2025 Topps Heritage Chrome Light Blue Sparkle Refractors #15 Jacob Wilson
$36.00
2025 Topps Heritage Chrome Light Blue Sparkle Refractors #15 Jacob Wilson
2021 Topps Gold Label Framed Autographs #FAMO Matt Olson
$36.00
2021 Topps Gold Label Framed Autographs #FAMO Matt Olson
2015 Immaculate Collection Immaculate Ink Holo Gold #18 Billy Butler/10
$30.00
2015 Immaculate Collection Immaculate Ink Holo Gold #18 Billy Butler/10
2003 Leaf Certified Materials Fabric of the Game Autographs #19IN Miguel Tejada IN/5
$35.00
2003 Leaf Certified Materials Fabric of the Game Autographs #19IN Miguel Tejada IN/5
2018 Topps Update Photo Variations #US95B Dustin Fowler/Tan bat
$27.00
2018 Topps Update Photo Variations #US95B Dustin Fowler/Tan bat
2022 Bowman Inception Primordial Prospects Autographs Blue #PPAMMY Max Muncy
$27.00
2022 Bowman Inception Primordial Prospects Autographs Blue #PPAMMY Max Muncy
2003 Fleer Fall Classics Pennant Aggression Game Patch #CH Catfish Hunter
$40.00
2003 Fleer Fall Classics Pennant Aggression Game Patch #CH Catfish Hunter
Ships Free
2002 Fleer Showcase Sweet Sigs Leather #5 Eric Chavez/20
$32.00
2002 Fleer Showcase Sweet Sigs Leather #5 Eric Chavez/20
2001 Leaf Certified Materials Mirror Gold #28 Barry Zito
$36.00
2001 Leaf Certified Materials Mirror Gold #28 Barry Zito
2001 Ultimate Collection Magic Numbers Game Jersey Copper #MNJAG Jason Giambi
$27.00
2001 Ultimate Collection Magic Numbers Game Jersey Copper #MNJAG Jason Giambi
1996 Leaf Preferred Steel Gold #14 Mark McGwire
$36.00
1996 Leaf Preferred Steel Gold #14 Mark McGwire
2019 Topps Museum Collection Signature Swatches Dual Relic Autographs Gold #SSDARL Ramon Laureano
$36.00
2019 Topps Museum Collection Signature Swatches Dual Relic Autographs Gold #SSDARL Ramon Laureano
1995 Donruss Press Proofs #460 Mark McGwire
$27.00
1995 Donruss Press Proofs #460 Mark McGwire
2001 Fleer Autographics Silver #97 Miguel Tejada
$36.00
2001 Fleer Autographics Silver #97 Miguel Tejada
2002 Topps 206 Carolina Brights #297A Mark McGwire A's RET
$27.00
2002 Topps 206 Carolina Brights #297A Mark McGwire A's RET
2018 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs #ROAKD Khris Davis
$27.00
2018 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs #ROAKD Khris Davis
2025 Topps Chrome Photo Variations #54 Brent Rooker
$30.00
2025 Topps Chrome Photo Variations #54 Brent Rooker
2002 Leaf Certified Fabric of the Game #36JN Miguel Tejada/4
$35.00
2002 Leaf Certified Fabric of the Game #36JN Miguel Tejada/4
2002 Leaf Certified Mirror Emerald #156 Mark Ellis NG Jsy
$28.00
2002 Leaf Certified Mirror Emerald #156 Mark Ellis NG Jsy
2023 Bowman Chrome Prospect Autographs Gold Shimmer Refractors #CPAYLY Yeniel Laboy
$27.00
2023 Bowman Chrome Prospect Autographs Gold Shimmer Refractors #CPAYLY Yeniel Laboy
2020 Topps Project 2020 #168 Rickey Henderson/6650*/Ermsy
$30.00
2020 Topps Project 2020 #168 Rickey Henderson/6650*/Ermsy
2002 Leaf Certified Fabric of the Game #109PS Mark Mulder/35
$36.00
2002 Leaf Certified Fabric of the Game #109PS Mark Mulder/35
2016 Bowman Chrome Turn Two Green Refractors #TTBO Franklin Barreto/Matt Olson
$30.00
2016 Bowman Chrome Turn Two Green Refractors #TTBO Franklin Barreto/Matt Olson
2020 Bowman Chrome Mega Box Rookie of the Year Favorites Autograph Refractors #ROYFAAJP A.J. Puk
$27.00
2020 Bowman Chrome Mega Box Rookie of the Year Favorites Autograph Refractors #ROYFAAJP A.J. Puk
2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Franchise Futures Signatures #88 A.J. Griffin/99
$27.00
2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Franchise Futures Signatures #88 A.J. Griffin/99
2003 Donruss Elite Career Bests Materials Autographs #20 Miguel Tejada HR Bat/25
$30.00
2003 Donruss Elite Career Bests Materials Autographs #20 Miguel Tejada HR Bat/25
2007 Bowman Chrome Prospects Orange Refractors #BC165 Chad Boyd
$27.00
2007 Bowman Chrome Prospects Orange Refractors #BC165 Chad Boyd
2020 Topps Archives Snapshots Walk-Off Wires Autographs #WWMTE Miguel Tejada
$30.00
2020 Topps Archives Snapshots Walk-Off Wires Autographs #WWMTE Miguel Tejada
2003 Fleer Platinum Portraits Game Patch #BZ Barry Zito
$32.00
2003 Fleer Platinum Portraits Game Patch #BZ Barry Zito
2003 Donruss Signature Autographs Notations Decade #69 Mark Mulder MSU
$35.00
2003 Donruss Signature Autographs Notations Decade #69 Mark Mulder MSU
2003 Bowman Chrome Gold Refractors #340 Gary Schneidmiller AU A
$42.00
2003 Bowman Chrome Gold Refractors #340 Gary Schneidmiller AU A
Ships Free
2021 Topps Clearly Authentic '86 Topps Autographs Black #86TBABZ Barry Zito
$40.00
2021 Topps Clearly Authentic '86 Topps Autographs Black #86TBABZ Barry Zito
Ships Free
2009 Bowman Chrome Prospects Gold Refractors #BCP9 Kelvin de la Cruz
$27.00
2009 Bowman Chrome Prospects Gold Refractors #BCP9 Kelvin de la Cruz